Russell Kelly Rebuts Shawn Hennessy Again, 2018
Shawn Hennessey: If you
tithe for a year and you are not better off, he will give you your 10% back! No questions asked.....
Russell E Kelly: These kinds of propositions are highly unethical and unbiblical. They are unethical because they
turn churches into houses of betting and gambling. They are unbiblical because they twist Holy Scripture and define the HOLY
tithe incorrectly. Finally, Shawn Hennessey will not defend his position in an open forum. The HOLY tithe
(as the word is used by Moses, Nehemiah, Malachi and Jesus) was always only FOOD from inside HOLY Israel. Therefore, neither
Hennessey, nor I, nor his congregation could biblically tithe even if they wanted to do so.
Hennessey: Why Isn’t God Blessing Me? Psalm 37:4 ESV Delight yourself in the LORD, and he will give you the
desires of your heart.
Kelly: Ps 37 is not about tithing. For King David, this meant
obeying all 600+ commandments, judgments and statutes of the Law.
Hennessey: Tzedakah = Justice,
Fairness, or Righteousness
Righteous = In Right Standing With God
Kelly: Tzedakah is the same word as justification
and righteousness in Hebrew; di-kai-o-su-ne means both justification and righteousness in Greek. Our right standing before
God is the imputed righteousness of Jesus Christ. It is not attained by tithing or works of the Law.
Hennessey: The Talmud =
The Body of Civil Law
Kelly: O. T. Judgments were civil law. O.
T. statutes and ordinances were ceremonial worship laws with included tithing. Why not discuss the Bible instead of the Talmud?
Hennessey: 2 Corinthians 9:7 NLT You must each decide in your heart how much to give. And don't give reluctantly
or in response to pressure. "For God loves a person who gives cheerfully.
Kelly: Yet you pressure
others to tithe while you ignore Numbers 18:20, own property and amass wealth. This post-Calvary N. T. teaching survives while
tithing ended (Heb 7:5, 12, 18) and now all believers are priests.
Hennessey: 2 Corinthians
8:7 NEV But as you excel in everything--in faith, in speech, in knowledge, and in all eagerness and in the love from us that
is in you--make sure that you excel in this act of kindness too.
Kelly: The context is freewill
giving of food supplies for starving saints in Judea. It is not about tithing. Sacrificial freewill giving also survives tithes
and does not include tithes.
Why do you quote 2 Cor 8:7 and 9:7? They counter tithing.
Hennessey: 1) Tithing Is A Test
Kelly: According to Deuteronomy 27-30,
the whole Law was a test: obey all to be blessed; disobey one and be cursed. Tithing WAS only a test for O. T. Israelite food
producers under the Old Covenant of Law. As a carpenter Jesus did not qualify.
Hennessey: Tithe = Tenth
Kelly: This is dishonest and Hennessey knows it. That is NOT the biblical description of the HOLY
tithe from the HOLY land of Israel. 16 texts from Lev 27 to Mt 23 define the holy tithe as only food. Be honest with God’s
Word or stop preaching.
Hennessey: Malachi 3:6 “For I am the Lord, I do not change;
therefore, you are not consumed, O sons of Jacob.
Kelly: Does this mean that
we should still offer animal sacrifices and observe all 600+ OT commands? The “you” are the dishonest priests
from 1:6; 2:1, 17 and 3:1-5. Most “sons of Jacob” disappeared into exile in 722 BC.
3:7 - Yet from the days of your fathers you have gone away from My ordinances and have not kept them.
Kelly: God is speaking only
to the priests and is answering their challenge and question from 2:17. Only priests’ ordinances are found in Malachi
Hennessey: Return to Me, and I will return to you,” says the Lord of hosts. “But you said, ‘In
what way shall we return?’
Kelly: This is still in the context
of the priests’ question in 2:17.
Hennessey: 8 - “Will a man rob
God? Yet you have robbed Me! But you say, ‘In what way have we robbed You?’ In tithes and offerings.
Kelly: Priests had robbed God in Mal 2:13-14 and Neh 13:5-10. Strangely, nobody preaches tithing from those texts.
Hennessey: 9 - You are cursed with a curse, for you have robbed Me, Even this whole nation.
Kelly: Why don’t your
quote your modern versions here? Most read “this whole nation of you --- meaning “of you priests” which
is the context of 2:13-14, 17 and 3:1-5. The priests had been cursed 4 x already in 2:13-14 and 2:1-2 --- every priest in
Hennessey: 10 - Bring all the tithes into the storehouse, that there may be food in My house, and test Me
now in this,” says the Lord of hosts, “If I will not open for you the windows of heaven and pour out for you such
blessing that there will not be room enough to receive it.
Kelly: (1) Tithes were still
only FOOD over 1000 years after Lev 27. (2) Since, the Temple did not have room to store all the tithes from the nation, tis
text only makes sense if it is only speaking to dishonest priests from 2:13-14 and Neh 13:5-10. (3) God would be cruel to
expect priests and Levites to travel to the Temple for their daily food. See Neh 10:37-38.
Hennessey: 2) Tithing Is
Biblical; Genesis 14:18-20
Kelly: It is dishonest to use Gen 14 to define holy tithes because
they were war booty from Sodom and Gomorrah which were not holy tithes under the Law. History proves that Abram was only obeying
the Semitic law of the land.
Hennessey: Genesis 28:22 Jacob tithed
Kelly: Again, it is dishonest to use this as an example of HOLY tithing. This was a freewill vow from the pagan land
of Haran of Babylon. It was not commanded.
Hennessey: Leviticus 27:30-34 is first
description of holy tithes.
Kelly: Yes, as only FOOD from
inside HOLY Israel. Money was very common even in Genesis but was never included in the description of HOLY tithes.
Hennessey: Deuteronomy 26:1-2
Kelly: These texts prove that even
First-fruits were always only FOOD from inside God’s HOLY land.
Hennessy: Deuteronomy 26:13-14
Kelly: Ministers of God were expected to remain among the poorest of the land which ate from the 2nd yearly
festival tithe which was EATEN by all in the streets of Jerusalem. Why does not Hennessey practice what he reads here?
Hennessy: Hebrews 13:8 NIV He’s the same yesterday, today and forever
Kelly: That certainly does
not mean that God wants us to stay under the Old Covenant system of sacrifices (and tithing). No tithe teacher obeys Numbers
18:20 and not own or inherit land and refuse to amass wealth? God’s character does not change but God does expecdt different
things from man under different covenants and dispensations.
Hennessey: Matthew 23:23
Kelly: This is very easily explained. (1) Before Calvary Jesus taught complete obedience of the Law, including tithes
to the Levitical system and not to Him or to His disciples. Otherwise He would have sinned. (2) Tithes were still only FOOD
over 1400 years after Leviticus 27. Which church collects tithes from back-porch garden spices?
Hennessey: Hebrews 7:1-8
These texts do not teach tithing. They teach the non-Hebrew high priesthood of Jesus. 7:12 teaches a necessary change of the
law (of the tithing laws from 7:5) and 7:18 says it was abolished. Why do tithe teachers stop explaining
Hebrews 7 before verse 12?
Hennessey: 3) Tithing Is A Benefit; 2 Chronicles 31 all.
Kelly: The only ones benefitting from Hezekiah’s mistake were the rats, birds and worms on the street. First,
he had mistakenly ordered all tithes to be brought to Jerusalem. Second, there were no facilities in Solomon’s temple
to store most of them. Read the whole chapter. Third, he had to build storerooms for some of the tithes. Fourth, most were
re-shipped back to the cities of the Levites. Does anybody read the whole chapter?
Please stop abusing and
twisting God’s Holy Word.
Russell Earl Kelly, PHD
October 7, 2018